Rating System

5 cauldrons

This was a fantastic book! Run, not walk, to the bookstore. Immediately. I will continue to rant and rave about this book for the next several years, so brace yourselves!

4.5 cauldrons

It was an excellent read, but it’s lacking a frustrating teeny weeny something.

4 cauldrons

This book only kept me up until 2am. If some of the problematic components were fixed, I definitely could’ve stayed up for a few more hours to finish it in one sitting…with some additional caffeine on board.

3.5 cauldrons

While there were some really great components, there were also a few flaws that irked me, and I had trouble seeing past them.

3 cauldrons

It was an okay book. It wasn’t great, but it’s wasn’t horrible either. I definitely won’t be rereading it, and I would hesitate to broadly recommend it.

2.5 cauldrons

The book was bland overall. While it doesn’t make the list of my top ten worst reads, there were definitely some areas that could have been improved upon.